Now, the most important thing in a slice-of-life shows is the characters. While I consider characters the most important part of all anime, as if you don't care about the characters, what's the point of watching them, this is especially true with slice-of-life anime, where the whole point is watching a random group of people mess around and do stuff. If these characters fall flat, then the show automatically falls flat too. A common complaint for the slice-of-life genre is that it recycles character archetypes a lot. Now, I personally consider that to be part of the genre and judge the characters not by whether we've seen their personality ten times before, but how much they add new stuff to their personality and become their own character. Now, Azumanga Daioh, being one of the first “a bunch of school girls mess around” show creating all of these archetypes we see so much in today's slice-of-life, the characters in Azumanga Daioh would be unique enough that everyone would want to rip them off, and the answer to that question is a big no.
While you don't go to slice-of-life shows looking for multi-layered characters, you can't just give them a personality and role with it, you need to flesh out the personality and add details to it and that is one thing Azumanga falls at miserably. The teacher, Yukarin, is lazy, Tomo is the energetic goofball, Chiyo is the small, cute, and smart one, Yomi is the straight man in the group, Osaka is the ditz, Sakaki is the tomboy who likes cute things, and Kagura... Is tomboyish? I guess? That's all there is to it. Nothing more. That's literally the whole show right there. These have to be some of the most one-sided characters I've seen in any slice-of-life anime.
So due to the fact we have a group of dull characters with only one or two traits to them, the comedy suffers. And there is no plot to this show, just comedy. Jokes get over-used all the time. Goofy, random stuff happens for no reason to be goofy and random, and some people might, but I do not find random humor to be that funny. Well, okay, maybe it's funny in all doses, but if I sit through a show where the whole purpose is goofy random humor, I just get used to the randomness and it isn't funny anymore. I didn't laugh once through the energetic comedy FLCL as the comedy just bounced off me as once I quickly got used to the randomness, you well, get used to the randomness and it doesn't become funny anymore. While Azumanga Daioh does try to pull out a more slow pace than other random comedies out there, in a way that's even worse as it drains whatever personality this show is trying to have even more. Not to mention that four episodes in, whatever comedy the show had quickly gets old as these are one-sided characters with nothing to them and they can't do much else besides act to their one-sided personality. Not to mention that this show reuses plots so much. Three beach episodes, 3 sport festival episodes,and 2 festivals. That means that 5 episodes in this show reuse plots from previous episodes. And stock footage too if I recall correctly.
Which brings me to my next negative on this show, the animation,which, to be honest, sucks. Characters never move while talking, the character designs are about as undetailed as you can get, with some of the cast even looking alike as there's little variation. Backgrounds are dull and just fade in. Footage is sometimes repeated for little reason expect to save money. The voice actors are also pretty mediocre too, but who can blame them with the terrible characters they're put into. The music is rather good though, with catchy background tunes and a very memorable opening and ending theme.
Azumanga Daioh Final Consensus
Story- Comedy falls flat and relies too much on randomness-3.
Characters- A terrible, one-sided cast-3.
Art-Very poor- 4.
Sound- Dull voice actors, good music-6.5.
Comedy anime around 2004 must have all sucked if this is seen as one of the greats in the genre (and now that I think about it, the only other comedy from around that time that I ever see get recommend is Cromartie High School, so perhaps that's true). Azumanga Daioh is everything a slice-of-life anime should not be. While you cannot ignore its influence on the genre and on anime in general, I still cannot recommend this to anyone. Overall, a score of 4.
